top of page

Broker Math vs Appraiser Math: The Cap Rate Cage Match
Broker: Underwritten at 6.25% cap, clean T-12, lender-ready Lender: Cool—reconcile 4 NOI definitions and prove snow removal is non-recurring Appraiser: Used comps from a 2008 bowling alley; concluded value = vibes minus TI 😐 Client: Can we close Friday with 80% LTC, non-recourse, and a rate lower than my espresso Me: Rebuilding Excel for the 7th time while the rent roll multiplies like Gremlins 🫠
ricklahkar
Jul 201 min read
Lender said 'no surprises'—then the appraiser hit reply-all
Broker: We're clear to close Lender: Need one last item—full SNDA/estoppels, fresh T-12, updated rent roll Appraiser: Used comps from a vacant alpaca mall 60 miles away, minus $2M for 'market vibes' 🤡 Me at 1:47 AM: Excel screams 'circular reference'; DSCR 1.30 -> 0.99; credit committee at 8 🧨
ricklahkar
Jul 191 min read
Appraisal Came In At Vibes Only
Broker: It’s a $12M deal at a 5.5 cap Appraiser: Pulled 3 comps from 2016 and a goat farm—calls it $9.2M Lender: DSCR 1.25, interest-only? LOL, proceeds cut, come back with more cash Me: Sweat equity? More like sweat + actual equity 😅 Seller: Price firm, 10-day close, hard at LOI, no retrades—good talk
ricklahkar
Jul 181 min read
Clear to Close* (*until the appraisal hits)
Broker: Clear to close Friday Lender: Recalced DSCR at 1.23 after market volatility 📉 Appraiser: Bumped cap rate 50 bps because Starbucks is 0.3 miles farther Me: Re-trading the rent roll and cuddling my Excel error column like a therapy dog 😵💫
ricklahkar
Jul 161 min read
Appraisal Came In At Vibes; Lender Needs 19 More Docs
Broker: 6.0 CAP, pro forma rents, easy close Lender: send updated T-12, T-3, T-0, and your childhood report card Appraiser: found a 2014 comp with gravel parking… minus $1.2M Me at 2am: rerunning Excel, IRR now = Irritated Rate of Return 😂
ricklahkar
Jul 151 min read
Appraisal Says $210/SF; My Term Sheet Thinks It’s 2019
Broker brain: Value supported by 3 comps at $325/SF, T-12 clean, DSCR 1.30 Appraiser: Two comps are from 2017 and one’s a funeral home; concluded $210/SF Lender: Proceeds reduced 30%. Also need an estoppel from the vending machine 🙃 Me at 2:03 AM in Excel: If Starbucks signs a 15-year before close, cap rate drops to 4.75 and math forgives me ☕️
ricklahkar
Jul 141 min read
Client: Close Friday; Lender: New DSCR; Appraiser: Here’s a Barn
Broker: DSCR pencils at 1.25 on my model Lender: Re-run with 8.5% vacancy, 10% mgmt, and replace rent with vibes Appraiser: Pulled a "comparable" barn from 2010 three counties away Client: So we’re still closing Friday, right? 🙂
ricklahkar
Jul 131 min read
Appraisal Came In Low And So Did My Will To Re-Trade
Broker: We modeled 5.0 cap, 1.25 DSCR, easy close Lender: Make it 1.35 DSCR, tax escrows, and a $300k TI/LC holdback Appraiser: Pulled comps from the haunted flex space with zero parking 📉 Me at 2am: Wrestling the circular reference like it owes me earnest money 😵💫
ricklahkar
Jul 121 min read
I Modeled 1.30x DSCR, Lender Modeled My Tears
Broker: Underwrote 1.30x DSCR, 6 cap, clean T-12—let’s party Lender: Apply 15% “economic vacancy,” 3 stress tests, and send as PDF, XLSX, and cave painting Appraiser: Used comps from a goat farm and a 2009 Sears—value “surprisingly conservative” 🤡 Client: Rate was 5.75% right? Reality: SOFR + vibes + points; Me: reopening Excel for the 8th time ☕
ricklahkar
Jul 111 min read
The DSCR Was 1.30 Until the Appraiser Opened Excel
Broker: DSCR's 1.30 on the T12, we're golden Lender: Upload rent roll, estoppels, SNDA, and your childhood report cards Appraiser: Comps from 2019, cap at 5.25% because 'vibes' 🧮 Client: Can we close Friday? Me: After the 12% value haircut and a fresh covenant tattoo? 😂
ricklahkar
Jul 101 min read
Appraisal Just Yeeted My DSCR (and My Will to Underwrite)
Broker: It pencils at 65% LTV and 1.31 DSCR, we’re golden Appraiser: Found a 2015 comp with gravel parking, value down 7% 🤡 Lender: Please add 10% vacancy for market sentiment and resubmit by noon Me: 2am Excel surgery moving $1 from below the line to NOI like a defibrillator 🥲
ricklahkar
Jul 91 min read
When the Appraisal Hits Like a Friday Afternoon Email
Expectation: 6% cap, clean T-12, lender thumbs-up Reality: DSCR 1.19, SNDA scavenger hunt, 'escrow holdback TBD' 🙂 Appraiser: pulled comps from a 2011 bowling alley two counties over Me in Excel: version_14_FINAL_v7.xlsx, cap rate crying, rent roll vs T-12 cage match 🤡
ricklahkar
Jul 81 min read
My Pro Forma Said 6 Cap; Lender Said “Cute”
Broker: Pro forma 6 cap, stabilized day one Lender: Cool - send T-12, T-3, rent roll, TI/LC, and your last three birthdays Appraiser: Adjusted for roof life, parking slope, and optimism - value equals lunch money 🍔 Me in Excel: If I hide Column G, DSCR magically > 1.25, right? 😬
ricklahkar
Jul 61 min read
Expectation: Lender Love. Reality: Appraisal Limbo.
Broker Brain: 6% cap, 1.35x DSCR—what a snack Lender: Upload T-12, T-3, T-1, T-Now, T-Never by 4:59pm Appraiser: Comped us to a 1978 warehouse with raccoons and a leaky roof 🦝 Me: Re-trading the deal while the client asks if interest-only is free 🤡
ricklahkar
Jul 51 min read
Appraisal Said It Depends And My Pro Forma Retired
Expectation: 75% LTV, 1.35 DSCR, appraise at contract Reality: Lender TS (subject to): T-12 scrub, estoppels, rate cap — 19 boxes, 0 souls left Appraiser: using 2019 comps + market feels — value haircut, buzzcut really Phase I: congrats, your parking lot used to be a dry cleaner with hobbies Excel: circular reference activated, IRR entered witness protection 😵💫
ricklahkar
Jul 41 min read
When The Appraiser Uses A 2009 Comp And My LOI Evaporates
Broker: DSCR pencils at 1.30 Lender: Need updated rent roll, T-12, T-3, and your blood type Appraiser: Valuation based on a 2009 comp next to a shuttered Sears 🤡 Me: Explaining to client how 60 bps + retrade + roof leak still equals great deal 🧮
ricklahkar
Jul 31 min read
DSCR Says Yes, Appraiser Says LOL
Expectation: 6% cap, clean Phase I, DSCR 1.30—easy win Reality: Lender needs T-12, T-3, T-1, T-now, and a rent roll notarized by a notary’s notary Appraiser: Pulled 2016 flex comps and deducted for “emotional obsolescence” 😵💫 Me in Excel: circular-reference boss fight while client asks if we can close by lunch Friday 🔥
ricklahkar
Jul 21 min read
When the Appraisal Hits Different and the Lender Stress-Tests My Soul
Broker: UW at 6 cap, 1.35x DSCR—victory lap Lender: SOFR sneezed, need 1.50x and a fresh T-12 by 4pm Appraiser: Best comp is a 2015 cornfield two counties over—adjusting for ‘vibes’ 🧮 Me to client: We’re still on track, just redefining ‘track’ as theoretical 😵💫🔥
ricklahkar
Jul 11 min read
When The Appraisal Values Your Sanity, Not Your NOI
Broker: We’re at 65% LTV, 1.35x DSCR, clean Phase I—easy close Lender: Perfect, just need estoppels, SNDAs, three rent rolls, and proof the roof isn’t lying Appraiser: Pulled a 2016 comp for “stability”; concluded value = vibes 📉 Me: Reclassifying TI for the 7th time so Excel whispers 1.26x instead of 1.24x 😵
ricklahkar
Jun 291 min read
Proforma: Easy Close — Lenders & Appraisers: Hold My Cap Rate
Broker: Proforma NOI is rock solid—just normalize the 'temporary' 35% vacancy Lender: Noted—DSCR 1.12, so lower LTV, partial recourse, and maybe your truck Appraiser: Great news—perfect comp if your asset was a 2009 C-class warehouse in a cornfield Me: Updating Excel v9 while the client asks for 30 months free rent 🫠
ricklahkar
Jun 281 min read
bottom of page
.png)